Article

Background Verification of Employees: How the Process Actually Works

Written by The CrimCheck Team

The CrimCheck Team produces expert content on background checks, police checks, employment screening, and compliance in Australia. Our specialists combine experience in digital strategy, risk management, and customer onboarding & support to deliver accurate, practical insights. Every article is reviewed for quality and relevance, informed by our work supporting organisations across Australia with fast, secure, and compliant screening solutions.

You send an applicant an invite, and at some point a result comes back. What happens in between is mostly out of sight, which is fine until there's a start date pencilled in and a manager asking if it's still on.

This guide walks through background verification of employees in Australia step by step, so you can set realistic expectations and spot where a check is likely to stall.

Step 1: The request and the applicant's consent

You can't run a police check without the applicant's informed consent. No accredited provider offers a covert option.

Sending the invite

Your provider's portal sends the applicant a personalised link, usually by email or SMS. With CrimCheck, applicants can complete their application online without a phone call.

The collection statement and consent

The applicant reads a Privacy Collection Statement explaining how their information will be used, then signs electronically to give explicit consent, in line with the Privacy Act 1988 and the Australian Privacy Principles.

Stating the purpose of the check

The applicant also states what the check is for, which shapes what police release. A general employment check is assessed under spent convictions rules, so minor matters older than ten years generally aren't released. The more fully the purpose describes the work the applicant will do, the better placed police are to judge when releasing a matter that would otherwise be spent is in the interest of public safety.

In aged care, for example, "care worker" tells police very little, while "personal care worker visiting older clients in their own homes" describes the job. Nothing is redacted: a matter is either released, or you never know it existed.

A certificate a candidate got for another role may not reflect yours, so running your own check, with the purpose written accurately, is best practice.

Step 2: Identity verification

Nothing goes to police until the applicant's identity is confirmed.

The three identity documents

Applicants provide three identity documents, one from each category: commencement of identity, primary use in the community and secondary use in the community. If their name has changed, they also provide evidence of the change, such as a marriage certificate.

Common examples include:

●    Australian passport

●    Australian driver licence

●    Medicare card

●    Australian birth certificate

Our list of accepted identity document types sorts them by category.

Document verification

Your provider then checks that each document is genuine and belongs to the applicant. Many can be matched electronically against the issuer's records, for example through the government's Document Verification Service (DVS). Others need another step, such as certification by an authorised person. You can read more about document verification here.

A common hold-up we see involves New Zealand or British passport holders who've lived here for decades and don't expect to need visa evidence, so the request comes as a surprise. Until it arrives, the check can't be lodged. A quick word with them before the invite goes out can save a round of back and forth.

Step 3: Lodgment and the name check

Once the application is complete, your provider lodges the check with the ACIC's National Police Checking Service.

No match, or a possible match

The applicant's details go to the National Police Checking Service Support System (NSS), where an initial computerised name check compares them against national police information. If there's no match, the result is no disclosable court outcome(NDCO). If the details match or potentially match a person of interest, the check is referred to state or territory police for manual review. Anything police release appears on the certificate as a disclosable court outcome (DCO).

Right to work through VEVO

If you also check right to work, passport details are run through the Department of Home Affairs' Visa Entitlement Verification Online (VEVO)system to confirm a visa holder's work conditions and expiry date. CrimCheck offers VEVO right to work checks.

Employment and qualification checks

If your process includes them, requests go to universities, registration boards and previous employers to confirm qualifications and work history. They sit outside the police check.

Step 4: Why some checks take longer than others

The majority of checks are approved within minutes of final lodgment. That's the point where the applicant has completed everything required and the check has been submitted to the ACIC.

Say an applicant uploaded everything on Monday and by Wednesday is wondering why nothing has come back. The check may still be waiting on ID that needs clarifying, missing visa evidence, or the paying organisation releasing payment. If that's your organisation, the last one is worth checking.

After lodgment, a longer wait usually means the check has been referred. Most checks referred for manual processing are returned within five to ten days, though some take longer, particularly at peak times. With a start date close, plan around that range and keep the applicant posted.

What happens in manual review

Once a check is referred, a state or territory police officer works out whether the record belongs to your applicant or is a false match. If it's theirs, police apply spent convictions legislation and the stated purpose before deciding what to release.

Common surnames take longer because there are more records to rule out. An applicant who's sure there's nothing to find can spend that wait wondering what they've forgotten, so tell them a referral on its own doesn't mean anything will be released.

Busy times of year

Manual referrals depend on people, so police agency staffing shapes the timing. Processing slows in February, when recruitment peaks nationally, and during school holidays. The last quarter is usually quicker. Little is processed over Christmas, and the backlog is cleared in January. There's more to why a police check can take longer than expected.

Why your applicant pool shapes turnaround

Turnaround reflects your applicant pool, not your provider. We've seen HR managers move from a retailer where almost every check returns no disclosable court outcome to a social services organisation where more applicants have DCOs. More referrals and longer waits follow, and it's natural to assume the new provider is slower, though the same would happen with any accredited body.

Step 5: The report and your review

Police have already applied spent convictions rules by this point, so the certificate shows only what can be released for the stated purpose. Your provider issues it with any other checks you ordered, covering verified identity, any disclosable court outcomes, right to work status if a VEVO check was run, and validated credentials if requested.

The hiring decision is yours, and a DCO is not an automatic no. Assess it against the inherent requirements of the role, looking at the applicant's age when the offence happened, how serious it was and how long ago it was. Together, these indicate residual risk.

Setting up background verification of employees with CrimCheck

When a check stalls the week before a start date, or a disclosable court outcome leaves you unsure, ring our Australian help desk and talk it through. The most common reason organisations tell us they left a previous provider is having no helpdesk to call.

Every business account starts with a conversation, so the setup fits how you recruit and you get help writing the purpose of each check correctly. We're a registered charity accredited with Social Traders as a social enterprise, so screening spend with us can count toward social procurement targets in some government contracts.

Talk to us about business police checks.‍

Back to Main Blog Menu